Worldbuilding: Who Claims Priority?

Everything your characters want to do will need some kind of resources to do it. Who controls those resources, and why?

This goes from something as small as getting some eggs from your own chicken flock to make scrambled breakfast, to buying, negotiating, or outright stealing the Phlebotinum, needed to make sure your Mad Science/Wizardry goes right… or someone else’s Goes Horribly Wrong.

Who has the resources to start with may be a matter of luck. You explored into wilderness, you came up with a new use for something everyone else discards, you got saddled with an unexpected inheritance. Who keeps resources can be a matter of grit, money, social pressure, or odder reasons. If you have a flock of egg-layers, you decided the time and effort was worth it to have that resource right at your fingertips. If you suddenly find you’ve been living in a HOA all this time and someone Does Not Like Chickens… well, then you can either give up and get eggs from the grocery store like everyone else, or you can launch a mad scheme to get a variance, or even destroy the association! Mwah-ha-hah….

Ahem.

Who keeps resources can also to a great deal depend on how important society at large thinks those resources are. For instance, after about 1598 AD in the Joseon Dynasty, forestry fell under the administration of the navy.

Yes, the navy. No, they didn’t have trees growing in the ocean, it’s way too cold for mangroves. (Though a fantasy where sizable trees did grow in cold salt water would be Really Cool.) What Joseon did have was ships. Ships that had been the key to smashing the Japanese navy; and while it took Ming forces to kill enough of the land troops to halt the invasions, even that wouldn’t have been enough if Hideyoshi’s followers had been easily able to ferry in reinforcements. They weren’t, because Admiral Yi Sun-sin beat them high, wide, and handsome; and with Hideyoshi dying about that time, surviving Japanese commanders decided enough was enough.

Joseon beat back the invasion, but the resulting destruction left a cultural mark. Not least because, scholars estimate, about twenty percent of the population – possibly some two million people – were now dead, with about a hundred thousand more vanished as slaves, and whole villages and farmlands laid waste. In some cases, destroyed so badly no one could live there anymore.

(If you want a comparison – between military and civilians the U.S. Civil War is estimated to have had somewhere between 600,000 to over a million dead, out of a population of about 30 million. As in about three percent of the total population. Hideyoshi’s invasion was devastating.)

What survivors knew was that the navy had saved them, and would need to save them again if Japan came back. Navies need ships. Ships need wood. Therefore, the navy got administration over forest lands, because they needed it most.

(In the king and ministers’ opinions, at least. Probably a lot of commoners as well, given the respect held for Yi Sun-sin to this day.)

One of the knock-on results of this is that when the Japanese occupied again post-1890, they took over forestry. Korean environments are still dealing with the results.

What do your characters need, to survive your story? Who has that resource? Why do they have it? A purely industrial resource may be simple for your characters to get their hands on, even if it’s expensive. A material of strategic importance – that’ll be a lot harder.

…And remember, if your characters are competing cooks in a bake-off with a prize worth millions, then simple butter and sugar may become strategically important!

19 thoughts on “Worldbuilding: Who Claims Priority?

    1. Who wouldn’t? 😉

      Seriously, I’ve lived in one place for three years that has a large pond/tiny lake with a walkway all around it. Great place to walk once in a while, quiet, you can see turtles if you luck out…

      And this year it was all posted with “off limits” signs, declaring it belonged to the local HOA and not the property that surrounds half of the lake.

      Not amused, no.

      Liked by 3 people

      1. Has anyone ever heard of an HOA that isn’t a blight upon the community and the people that live anywhere near it?

        Liked by 2 people

      2. Actually, yes — I believe I’ve heard of a few specific-purpose ones that maintain a neighborhood pool/playground or handle mowing a bunch of inconveniently narrow little lawns or something along those lines, and stay in their lane instead of trying to control everything.

        That said, it seems plausible that a neighborhood where everybody there So Far has chipped in for joint lawncare might not be thrilled about somebody in the middle deciding to put a knee-high pollinator garden in the front and chickens/veggies in the back, so…

        Liked by 4 people

      3. Has anyone ever heard of an HOA that isn’t a blight upon the community and the people that live anywhere near it?

        Well, it hasn’t been around long enough to find out whether it will be a blight or not, but my family has property that is part of a “road and sewer association”… since Grandpa isn’t around to run his pet septic system that all the neighbors are hooked up to.

        I think everyone is hoping that if the association’s purpose is spelled out explicitly in the name, it won’t metastasize past its original purpose

        Liked by 3 people

      4. So as someone who lives in a place where we’ve got dozens of little water and sewer associations where the main problem is the secretary (as in officer worker secretary) periodically deciding it’s okay to skim a little off the top, that road and sewer association might not actually go awry in the way the HOA’s do.

        Just be sure they keep up to date on their audits yeah?

        Liked by 3 people

      5. Check the local land records.

        Good chance they don’t own it.

        If they do, betcha there’s some rules to allow walking, whatever the local version of easement is.

        Liked by 2 people

  1. Yeah, not something that crossed my mind. Oops?

    In conflict, the vast majority of resources would belong to Julius’s family. Unfortunately, since they are up against his cousin Nero… That’s probably not a good thing.

    Then again, the Airrunner Fleet would have resources of their own. I just have to figure out what is where…

    Liked by 2 people

    1. To be fair, part of the reason I write posts like this is because I stumble on a subject and say, “Oops, I’d better make sure I consider this, at least in an edit!”

      And yeah, if it’s all in the family that means getting and maintaining access to resources will be a nightmare, as various family members angle with who they believe is in the right – or who they think is going to come out on top, take your pick.

      Naval fleet resources can be amazingly far-flung. Look at Britain getting lumber and ship’s masts from the colonies!

      Liked by 1 person

  2. It’s also presumably behind a lot of opposition to the MC.

    In a lot of stories, there’s various people and institutions throwing their weight around and the MC is constantly asking “Why can’t they just leave me alone?” and since we see it from the MC’s perspective, it’s just framed as corruption or tyrannical behavior.

    Then you step back and realize that the MC is running around grabbing Strategic Assets and burning through resources, and in some cases outright destroying public property.

    “I followed the Spring of Healing back to the source and there was a Super Gem of Healing there! So I ate it.”

    “You destroyed the Spring of Healing? That everyone uses to survive?”

    “Well, I needed it more.”

    “Right. Would it be possibly for you to go fight off the demon army? We’re having trouble holding them off without the Spring of Healing.”

    “Aww dammit, why does everyone keep trying to take away my freedom?”

    ***

    Or in some cases, the MC has some cheat or system that supplies all the resources they need, or allows them to act without them, so they keep it secret, but everyone reacts as if they are hoarding.

    Because how else would they be able to do all this?

    Liked by 5 people

    1. I try very hard to make sure my characters never pull something like that….

      Heh. For example, Chae has gotten quite a bit of gold over her lifetime. But everyone knows what cultivators and especially Chae use that for – various arrays that can’t be made or permanently anchored any other way!

      So. Is she rich? Technically, yeah, but more like the same way the guy who maintains the armory is “rich”. Lots of books, lots of supplies, and she’s worked out a deal to have a safe place to work on all of it in exchange for putting that to demon-hunting use.

      …And yes, there are still people who (by their lights) rightfully resent and oppose her, because she chose to abandon proper filial piety to the Emperor by taking her highly trained self somewhere else.

      Liked by 3 people

  3. The Navy was also associated with trees in Britain. IIRC, there was a story about an admiral who carried around acorns in his pockets to plant wherever he found a good place.

    There was also a British writer who wrote contemptuously of American forest because after all, it was just natural. In Britain, if there were trees, you knew there was a great landlord nearby.

    Though the conflict over trees went much deeper than that. You can’t use oak for masts, it’s too heavy. You need evergreens. They had been using Scandinavian, and discovered to their relief that they could find even better ones in the American colonies, ones that didn’t even have be put together because the trees were tall enough! And you force the Americans to go through a whole rigmarole to bring down the tree intact and pay them no more than for ordinary lumber.

    Then the American Revolution hit. Oops.

    How much lack of masts affected their fighting is disputed, but it was more than zero.

    Liked by 1 person

  4. Another strategic resource the British went to a lot of trouble to get their hands on was quinine – this is the origin of the gin and tonic cocktail. I listened to a really good podcast episode on it at 99% Invisible. The episode is “The Fever Tree Hunt.”

    Liked by 2 people

  5. Roughly there are levels of response in my story. Level zero is theoretical, so it truly starts at 1. Each level involves more of the Adventurer pool, yet also lessens personal choice. Customized-to-fit training at the lower levels changes to generic, cookie cutter batch training at higher levels. That batch training doesn’t pass on the little tips and tricks that turn a good Adventurer into a heroic one. Think the difference between Simo hayha and a just graduated sniper.

    Like

Leave a comment