On Writing: Title, Summary, Augh

AKA you wrote it, now what do you call it? And how do you sum it up – whether for a book blurb or a fic-posting site?

…Yeah, no, I’m not good at this. I face Title and Summary boxes with a look of stunned, deer-in-headlights, “Now what?” I spent all this time and effort coming up with an Idea and getting it down in words, and you expect me to sum it up?

Alas, we must. I mean, you can’t title a book “Every Neat Fictional Trope Slammed into a Firecracker of a Story!”

…Well, you could, but fitting it on your cover is going to be a bear and a half.

Which is a good place to start if you’re absolutely stuck on a title. What would look good on the front cover?

Hopefully this narrows down the horde of possibilities to something more manageable. Three to five words is usually good; if you’re using a one-word title like Dracula, you’re going to need a really good back cover blurb. If you’re using a subtitle, people usually think nonfiction. Things like that.

Puns, now. People have widely differing opinions on those. I personally consider a punny title one of the factors that will make me stop and read the cover blurb, and maybe the sample. I like puns. That said, if you have a punny title you’re implying there will be wry humor in the book as well. This fits for cozy mysteries, lighter fantasy and SF, and any other work where the characters can see some humor in their own situation. It’s not the vibe you want if you’re doing Deadly Serious stuff. The Wheel of Time? Serious. Eric Flint’s Pyramid Schemes? Not so much.

Also, puns generally don’t translate well, as anyone who’s written in an anime or foreign drama fandom can attest. This may or may not be important to you, but if you are trying to market internationally… well, it’s something to think about.

Proverbs may translate a bit better. I’ve been known to snag a saying or two as a title inspirations. Combine the right saying with a good cover, and you can strongly hint at the conflict of the story before your readers even read the blurb.

Or the summary. The two are not the same thing! A summary should give a general idea of the whole story. A blurb, in contrast, should only cover maybe the first third of the book, up to the first Major Conflict. Blurbs need to be short! Just enough to hook your reader in for more.

Remember, you don’t need to get them right the first time. Just like your story, it’s okay to do multiple drafts of your title, blurb, and so on.

Though do try to have the title final before you publish. It’s so much simpler that way…..

27 thoughts on “On Writing: Title, Summary, Augh

  1. How about THE TITLE WHICH COMBINES WITH THE BLURB AND THUS SETS THE STAGE FOR THE ENTIRE CONFLICT!SOMETIMES WITH HUMOROUS ~~EXCLIMATION POINTS~~ PUNCTUATION!?!?And maybe corrections!

    Which is also signaling to the reader- this is likely anime inspired, and it may deal with serious topics, but there will be humor, as well. Think Slayers! (where every episode’s title was like this, and yelled by the protagonist in announcer voice) and the current wave of various anime that was recruited from fic sites.

    I just really wanted to write a paragraph-title. ^.^

    Liked by 2 people

  2. And be aware of genre. I have come to a grudging understanding of long titles in fic. In my professional fiction? Noooot so much.

    And the conventions for blurbs on the front cover can change! I still remember a book from my childhood, and where we had it in the house, but not the title, where the blurb on the front cover was “Never screw with the mommy…” with a woman holding a dagger and sidling along a tree with a dark monster/satyr creeping around the trunk behind her. I can tell you the story and basic plot! I just. Can’t tell you the title or author. My brain has that. There are a few books that I’d like to revisit from back then but all I remember is the cover and story itself. And where it was located. (The home bookshelves have been moved a lot, and the library was my middle school library. I make no hope of it being still there.)

    Liked by 2 people

    1. Incidentally, that author has started writing again– the covers are definitely not the same style as way back when, but it’s still her, and I think she’s got some pen names, too. (Not that I can remember beyond “oh, that’s right, didn’t Holly Lisle get mentioned as having pen names?)

      Liked by 2 people

      1. Apparently there’s an old podcast episode where she talked about them. Kate Aeon is one of them and Holly Lisle Deaton is another, but apparently she had a ton in mind.

        Since Holly Lisle is obviously the better-known name, sanity seems to have come back to the world and she’s mostly reprinting stuff under her own name instead of some pseudonym.

        But she’s trying to publish some kind of urban fantasy series under a pseudonym, which just kills me, because she’s not just telling people the pseudonym, either. I gather that if you sign up for her email list, you get the super-sekrit info revealed.

        Of course this is probably some kind of tradpub madness forcing her to do this, because tradpub can’t do anything straightforward. (Instead of just saying, “We know you know the name Holly Lisle, and you know she can write!”)

        Liked by 3 people

      2. It might be as little as that she doesn’t seem to be getting signed on anymore– I know at one point they were refusing to sign basically anybody who didn’t become a stealth best seller, and a lot of authors (being artists, after all) went all in on the “it must be because I suck” bandwagon. Not realizing that basically winning the lotto was needed to sell massive amounts without any kind of publisher support. (HEck, TERRY PRATCHETT couldn’t manage to sell in the US until he got a publisher that didn’t warehouse his stuff!)

        Liked by 2 people

  3. I try to go for themed titles, where I can, i.e. “this is something that repeats in the story, so I’ll use that as a title.” *Debris* is a theme title, as it references the ripple effect of what – or who – is considered “debris” and how that the characters must live with that. The word itself doesn’t repeat much but the motif is there all the same.

    Other titles I have are punny, like *Contact: Angeles.* That title is a play on a lot of things: the Catholic prayer the Angelus, for one, and the Latin word for angels for another. Then there’s “first contact,” “contact with the enemy,” and “contact with alien life,” all of which can be ambiguous if you’re not careful. Is this person or creature a threat or not? If not, should we trust it? If it is a threat, how do we deal with it?

    For *In Dreams and Other Stories*, since it was a collection, I had to pick out the main theme of all the stories for the blurb. The title story has the action happening in a Dreamworld and so the title for that came easily. Putting together a summary that would fit the themes of the various stories (the main theme being “don’t mess with people who love their families”)? That took a little more work….

    Liked by 1 person

  4. Personally, I’m annoyed by the rhetorical question summaries:

    Will he find his family and fight off the dark side attempting to take him over?

    I’m contrary enough that my immediate response is to imagine the opposite of whatever the author is going for, then I end up thinking about how much more interesting that would be…

    Liked by 3 people

    1. Yes. Those can be very annoying. It’s probably why I framed the final lines for the blurb for *Debris* thus:

      “Neither Ayar nor Rhys ever expected to meet one another. But now that they have, maybe together they can fight for both their kinds. First, though, they need to learn how to communicate – and hope that neither of them is killed before they can get their enterprise off the ground!

      Welcome to the first book in the Rise of the Discarded series!”

      Not a question mark in sight – but plenty of questions!

      Liked by 1 person

    2. Ironically that is how the Mistborn series came about according to Brandon Sanderson. He started wondering what a world would be like of the Chosen One made the wrong choice at the final confrontation.

      Liked by 3 people

  5. Oh, wow, do I feel this one. Titles are Not Easy. Blurbs are worse, especially when dealing with a relatively small character limit. Especially when you only even decided something was ready for posting the day before you do it, and it has to be that day or it won’t have the desired impact. My latest fic was meant as an April Fool’s gag, and I only determined could be cut off at a convenient point to make a complete first chapter about two days before this April 1st.

    I was lucky in that the first sentence of the story was, itself, somewhat suited to be used for a blurb, but I still ended up relying mostly on my own name recognition in the fandom to get people interested. Which does seem to have worked, fortunately… possibly a bit too well. (Sigh. So many ideas, so little energy.)

    Liked by 2 people

  6. Well, obviously it’s up to us, our Queen’s devoted readership, to help crowdsource a list of potential novel titles!

    1. {Insert Title Here}
    2. “TBD” (Book 1 of the TLA chronicles)
    3. “This Book’s Title Is So Awesome, We’re Not Allowed To Print It!” 
    4. {HypnoToad says this is the most awesome novel title you can imagine (hail the hypnotoad!)}
    5. (ChatGPT_Prompt=”Awesome {trope} Novel Titles, 5 words or less, American English, Profanity_Allowance=0%)
    6. This Title Block Is Being Auctioned Off For Charity (see flyleaf for details)
    7. (Complete the crossword puzzle in each title header to find this book’s title!)
    8. Choose Your Own Title (Hey, TSR, don’t sue us, we’re broke!)
    9. Plotbunnies! PLOTBUNNIES EVERYWHERE!
    10. The PlotBunnies Ate This Title
    11. Look, Titles Are Hard, Okay?
    12. I Can’t Think Of A Title And I Have A Deadline

    Liked by 3 people

    1. “Look, Titles Are Hard, Okay?”

      The struggles of an English viscount, having to divide his time between his estate and politicking in the House of Lords. Meanwhile, to further complicate his life, he has no son to inherit his title. Instead, he has a very silly wife, and five daughters — three of whom are equally silly, and the youngest has just run off with someone totally unsuitable. (Totally Original Plot, Do Not Steal).

      Liked by 2 people

      1. It does occur to me that those kinds of stories are hardly ever told from the perspective of the man in that situtation…

        Liked by 1 person

  7. Punny titles make me think of wit and snark as well, both of which I really like.

    My Dragon Rider AU that I’m working on I have no idea what to call. An acquaintance suggested “Ride of the Beaters” which I don’t think fits at all but I went with anyway because I had no better ideas.

    On the other hand, a fresh idea I had for a Sekirei cross I’m calling Blades of a Feather, which I like a whole lot more than the working title for my Dragon AU.

    I’m not good at blurbs either, sometimes I can get them, sometimes I can’t. And then there’s the fact that some of the blurbs I think up are too long

    Liked by 2 people

  8. At one extreme, there’s the titles that came first, and the story after. That’s how Jewel of the Tiger got its start.

    At the other, there’s scrambling for a title while all the other ducks are lined up and waiting. That’s when A Diabolical Bargain got its. (I had thrown a title on it, but wasn’t happy.)

    And the worst are stories that are both. Crow Curse started with a title — but it wasn’t Crow Curse.

    Liked by 2 people

    1. The worst of the last minute was is that “Does it look good on a cover?” can also be “Does the cover look good with it?” Length is the chief consideration, I grant you.

      Liked by 2 people

  9. I tend towards the descriptive. First Stamp, Misplaced Demon Lord, Second Rebirth of Magic, Lands of Paradox, ect.

    Lands of Paradox is RWBY inspired, keeping the feel of the first two-and-a-half seasons with a dollop of Persona 2.

    Misplaced Demon Lord is about a Demon Lord…who grew up with a loving mom and is an active cleric.

    Second Rebirth of Magic is a multi-crossover that eventually will head to Star Trek Territory. Granted, It’s going to be wacky. Probably as a result of Shubb-Nigurath’s drunken escapades and Hasta-chan’s boyfriend.(She is by far the sane one in the relationship,believe you me) Heck, even Harry and Natsumi are going to cause conniptions. Hermione Gummer included…

    First Stamp is going to be LONG. Justifiably so, considering the endpoint. Started it out of nostalgia for Shin Megami Tensei IMAGINE, the only MMORPG that I loved.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Book Summary for Second Rebirth of Magic.

      This is the story of a rather wild universe. Eldritch gods getting drunk-married. Divine Champions with Ship-reincarnations, backed up by reformed monsters. This is how it starts… With a madman trying to recover lawn gnomes in Cult Capital USA. Where it ends? No one knows. Just watch out for the Slaves Of Ebon Ju-Oh…

      Book Summary for Misplaced Demon Lord.

      There is a prophecy among the Demons. That a Demon Lord greater than the Last one will arise. He United the Races of Light and Dark.. Against him. His Spite caused unending war.. If only they hadn’t screwed up Valaria’s conception, maybe this would be a grim tale. Includes! Reasonable Authority Figures! Cleric Protagonist! Useless Lesbians! And a whole lot more! *Eldritch Doombeasts Free of charge*

      Like

  10. Book Summary for First Stamp

    Hey, It’s Me. Aelin. I filled out a Waifu Quest-thing on a lark. Then the Real Company hired me. Oh yeah, they want me to Stamp an Eldritch Space Whale at the end of my journey. Thank God I chose some good Waifus.. I am a gonna Die a LOT I think. Considering I have two unknowing Maidens of Destruction and two girls who could pick their teeth with a zombie apocalypse, I should be able to survive my favorite MMORPG in real life.Wish me luck.

    Book Summary for Lands of Paradox.

    There was a reason why Ruby was in the Dust shop so late at night.. Now Weis s is about to discover things unlike anything she had ever known. Rogi and Igor. Nyartholep and Philemon. A bargain made. A trial for Team RWBY. A harbinger. Of Destruction or Salvation? The Boomhammer is going to hit the Fan-Wizard soon…

    Like

Leave a comment